Fw:Request:AuditofBeniciaPDFlock/ALPRaccesslogsinlightof SFPDfindings

File: Fw_ Request_ Audit of Benicia PD Flock_ALPR access logs in light of SFPD findings-Redacted (7).pdf Request: PR-2026-181 Sent: 2026-06-18 00:00:00 +0000 UTC Type: document Size: 209 KB OCR'd image-only scan

View the original PDF →

Sent: 6/18/202610:54:11AM From: SteveYoung<Young> To: "Edward"<Criado>"Mario"<Giuliani> Cc: "Mark"<Menesini> Bcc: Importance:Normal Subject:Fw:Request:AuditofBeniciaPDFlock/ALPRaccesslogsinlightof SFPDfindings GetOutlookforiOs From: Sent:Thursday,18June202610:52:14 To:MarkMenesini<MMenesini@ci.benicia.ca.us> <SYoung@ci.benicia.ca.us>;LionelLargaespada<LLargaespada@ci.benicia.ca.us> s Caution:Thisemailoriginatedfromoutsideof theorganization.Donotclicklinksoropenattachmentsunlessyourecognizethe Chief Mensini, senderandknowthecontentissafe. I'mwritingasaBenicia resident following Wednesday'sdisclosurebySFPD(https://missionlocal.org/2026/06/federal-agencies-sf-surveillance-flock-data-audit)thatanauditfound299improperqueriesof itsFlockALPRnetworkoverthepastyear,conductedonbehalfoffederaland out-of-stateagencies.ChiefLewdescribeditas"apparentlyastatewideissue," andtheaccessranthroughtheNorthernCaliforniaRegional IntelligenceCenter(NCRiC),withsearchestracedtoWesternStatesInformationNetworkanalysts. Giventhatpathway,I'dliketoask: 1.DoesBeniciaPDshareitsALPRdatawith,orgrantqueryaccessto,NCRICoranyotherfusioncenter? 2.HasBeniciaPDconducted anaudit of itsFlockaccesslogstodeterminewhetherfederal orout-of-stateagencieshavequeriedourdata,and ifso,whatdid it epuy 3.What isthecurrent stateof the"national lookup"/nationwideand statewidesearchsettingsonoursystem?Are they stilldisabled?Areyouaware that there is anymechanismtoget around them? 4.Willthedepartmentcommittoapublic-facingauditofaccesslogs,asseveralotherCaliforniacitieshavedone?Currentlythepubliclogsdonotofferthe informationnecessarytotracksuchinformation. Californialaw(SB34)prohibitssharingALPRdatawithout-of-stateagencies,soI'd appreciateclarityonhowthedepartmentverifiescomplianceratherthan relyingonFlock'svendor-side settings. Thankyouforyourtime.I'dwelcomeawrittenresponseandamhappytodiscussfurther. Best reaards.

Public Records Exemptions Enclosed please find a copy of the response documents for your public process employed to review and produce the response documents. Reason Description Pages 1 of 1